Category: Alberta Serious Incident Response Team (ASIRT) |

Search

Search for:
Contact Us

contact@globalshock.org
Menu
Categories
- ►1. COUNTRIES (4648)
  - Afghanistan (10)
  - Algeria (7)
  - Antigua (3)
  - Argentina (8)
  - Australia (274)
  - Austria (8)
  - Bahamas (1)
  - Bangladesh (1)
  - Barbados (1)
  - Belgium (4)
  - Belize (8)
  - Bermuda (5)
  - Brazil (44)
  - British Virgin Islands (2)
  - Cambodia (1)
  - Canada (Quebec also under “Quebec”) (305)
  - Canary Islands (4)
  - Cayman Islands (3)
  - China (6)
  - Colombia (1)
  - Croatia (1)
  - Cyprus (1)
  - Czech Republic (10)
  - Denmark (1)
  - Dubai (United Arab Emirates) (2)
  - Egypt (12)
  - England (see United Kingdom) (1)
  - Estonia (2)
  - European Union (6)
  - Finland (6)
  - France (107)
  - Germany (18)
  - Ghana (2)
  - Great Britain – see UK (1)
  - Greece (2)
  - Guam (US territory) (2)
  - Guernsey (2)
  - India (26)
  - Indonesia (3)
  - Iraq (14)
  - Ireland (10)
  - Israel (43)
  - Italy (9)
  - Jamaica (2)
  - Japan (1)
  - Jersey (4)
  - Jordan (1)
  - Laos (1)
  - Libya (2)
  - Macedonia (1)
  - Malaysia (13)
  - Maldive Islands (1)
  - Malta (6)
  - Mexico (11)
  - Mongolia (1)
  - Morocco (2)
  - Netherlands (14)
  - New Zealand (111)
  - Nigeria (1)
  - Pakistan (2)
  - Palestine (6)
  - Philippines (2)
  - Poland (4)
  - Portugal (8)
  - Quebec (63)
  - Réunion (3)
  - Romania (2)
  - Russia (5)
  - Samoa (US territory) (1)
  - Saudi Arabia (1)
  - Senegal (4)
  - Serbia (1)
  - Singapore (11)
  - Slovakia (1)
  - South Africa (14)
  - South Korea (16)
  - Spain (11)
  - Sri Lanka (1)
  - Sweden (5)
  - Switzerland (28)
  - Taiwan (1)
  - Tchad (2)
  - Thailand (12)
  - Trinidad & Tobago (9)
  - Turks & Caicos Islands (1)
  - UK (including Northern Ireland) (368)
  - Ukraine (1)
  - USA (1093)
  - Vietnam (4)
  - Yemen (2)
- 2. EDITORIALS (5)
- ►3. IN-DEPTH (56)
  - Government commission on tasers (1)
- 4. en français (129)
- ►5. GENERAL INDEX (13445)
  - Aardvark Tactical Inc. (USA) (3)
  - Aboriginal (see “indigenous”) (1)
  - Access to taser download data (4)
  - Accidental taser firing (2)
  - Aegis Corp: “Axeos” testing device (1)
  - Air taser (1)
  - AIR-107U (Russian) (2)
  - Airlines (18)
  - Airport security (2)
  - Alberta Serious Incident Response Team (ASIRT) (2)
  - Alcohol (39)
  - Alzheimer’s disease (10)
  - American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) (58)
  - American Coll. Emerg. Physicians (2)
  - American College of Emergency Physicians (1)
  - American Medical Assoc. (AMA) (4)
  - American Psychiatric Assoc. (APA) (2)
  - Amnesty International (172)
  - Amphetamines (1)
  - Animal research (13)
  - Animals tasered (15)
  - Anti-Felon Identification tags (AFID) (4)
  - Anti-gang weapon (5)
  - Appeals court (23)
  - Appeals court summation (7)
  - Arms trade (less lethal weapons) (13)
  - ArmStar Corporation (1)
  - Art (3)
  - Asperger’s syndrome (3)
  - Asphyxia-caused death (1)
  - Assault Intervention Device (AID) (1)
  - Assoc.Police Chiefs (APCO-UK) (9)
  - Asthma (3)
  - Asylum seekers (7)
  - Australian Civil Liberties Union (1)
  - Australian Medical Assoc. (1)
  - Autism (11)
  - Autopsy report (125)
  - Autopsy report altered (7)
  - Axon – EVIDENCE.com (69)
  - Axon cost (7)
  - AXON reliability (3)
  - Bad cop syndrome (16)
  - Bath salts (9)
  - Behavioural research (1)
  - Bicyclist tasered (2)
  - Bipolar disorder (8)
  - Blind victim (6)
  - Body-worn cameras and privacy (2)
  - Body-worn video cameras (28)
  - Border guards (21)
  - Braindead (1)
  - Breathing problems (1)
  - Bureau des enquêtes indépendantes (Quebec) (2)
  - Bystander tasered (15)
  - Bystanders protest taser use (3)
  - C2 (“Lady Taser”) (14)
  - Call for indep. research (13)
  - Calling 911 for medical help … (1)
  - Campaign against tasers (53)
  - Canadian Assoc. Chiefs Police (CACP) (3)
  - Canadian Civil Lib. Ass. (CCLA) (2)
  - Canadian Civil Liberties Assoc. (13)
  - Canadian Mental Health Association (22)
  - Cardiac arrythmia/arrest (85)
  - Cardiologists and tasers (1)
  - Chaotic Unmanned Personal Intercept Drone (CUPID) (2)
  - Child custody dispute (4)
  - Children (105)
  - Citizen forum on tasers (2)
  - Citizens buy tasers for police (1)
  - Civil libertarian lawyers (64)
  - Class action suit (1)
  - Coalition against tasers (San Francisco) (1)
  - Coalition Against The Taser (CATT: New Zealand) (4)
  - Coalition pour le retrait du Taser (Quebec) (6)
  - Coban Tech (on-body cameras) (1)
  - Cocaine (33)
  - Collateral damage (6)
  - Coma following taser (9)
  - Complaints (32)
  - Compliance (155)
  - Conjugal conflict (1)
  - Contradictory commands (1)
  - Coroner’s report / autopsies / post-mortems (206)
  - Corruption & Crime Commission (CCC: Australia) (5)
  - Cost of taser rollout (1)
  - Council of Europe (5)
  - Counter-insurgency (17)
  - Crime and Misconduct Commission (CMC: Queensland) (3)
  - Crime-rates and tasers (34)
  - Criminals using tasers (43)
  - Crisis intervention police training (7)
  - Crisis Intervention Training (CIT) (52)
  - Critical stress amnesia (1)
  - Cross-border purchases (2)
  - Cross-nation reporting (39)
  - Crowd control (93)
  - CUPID (1)
  - Cutbacks and tasers (2)
  - Cyclist tasered (1)
  - De-escalation (31)
  - Deaf victim (6)
  - Death (incomplete) (201)
  - Death caused by accident (1)
  - Defibrillator (2)
  - Deinstutionalization and tasers (1)
  - Delayed death (+ 4 days … ) (13)
  - Dementia (13)
  - Demonstrators (38)
  - Deportation (18)
  - Diabetes (10)
  - Diplomatic conflict (3)
  - Disability Rights (Vermont) (1)
  - Domestic Violence (3)
  - DOMILL (UK) (4)
  - Down’s syndrome (7)
  - Drones (UAVs) (15)
  - Drowning (1)
  - Elderly victims (48)
  - Elecrocardiologists (3)
  - Elite police unit (incl. SWAT teams) (35)
  - Emergency medical intervention (EMS) (8)
  - Ending taser use (2)
  - Epilepsy Foundation (USA) (4)
  - Epileptic seizure (18)
  - European Convent. Human Rights (3)
  - Eviction of otherwise homeless (1)
  - Eviction using tasers (2)
  - Excited delirium (106)
  - Excited delirium (statistics) (3)
  - Extinguishiung fire (1)
  - Extreme right-wing (8)
  - Falling to death (or serious injury) (34)
  - Familiar Inc. (2)
  - Family of victim (109)
  - Fatal risks (19)
  - FBI (US) (3)
  - FBI-LEEDA (US Police Assoc-n) (1)
  - Federal Aviation Authority (FAA: USA) (5)
  - Federal court judgment (US) (9)
  - Fibrillation (6)
  - FIFA World Cup (2014) (1)
  - Fire danger (3)
  - Fire risks (22)
  - Firearms officers (UK) (33)
  - Firefighters using taser (2)
  - First reponders (11)
  - Flashball (8)
  - Following orders (6)
  - Forced to taser (3)
  - Freedom-of-information access (3)
  - Future of tasers (40)
  - G8-G20 (9)
  - Gambling in street (2)
  - Gang Suppression Unit (GSU: Belize) (4)
  - Gang violence (18)
  - Gaza flotilla (8)
  - Gaza relief supply (1)
  - Generic tasers (37)
  - Graffiti (10)
  - Green Party (22)
  - Greenpeace (1)
  - Guidelines for taser use (209)
  - Gun mistaken for taser (4)
  - Gun shows (2)
  - Guns vs. taser use (122)
  - Hammer threatening police (3)
  - Head injury (6)
  - Heart attack then tasered (1)
  - Heart disease (19)
  - Heroin (1)
  - Hijacking (2)
  - History of tasers (2)
  - Homeland Security (USA) (11)
  - Homeless (22)
  - Hospitals (use in) (22)
  - Hostage-taking (6)
  - Human rights commission (2)
  - Humour (according to us!) (13)
  - Hunting with a taser (5)
  - Hurricane Katrina (1)
  - ICON Injection Moulding Inc. (USA) (1)
  - Illegal immigrants (5)
  - Immigrants & asylum-seekers (43)
  - Import restrictions (5)
  - Increasing transparency (8)
  - Indep. Police Complaints Commission (IPCC: UK) (31)
  - Independent Investigations Office (British Columbia) (4)
  - Independent Investigations Office (IIO: British Columbia) (1)
  - Independent Police Conduct Authority (New Zealand) (1)
  - Independent research (70)
  - Indigenous population (63)
  - Initiation rite (6)
  - INQUEST (UK group: deaths by police … ) (2)
  - Inst. for Prev. of In-Custody Deaths (IPICD: USA) (3)
  - Insurance companies & tasers (7)
  - Int. Assoc. Chiefs of Police (USA: IACP) (14)
  - Internet sales of “tasers” (1)
  - Invitation to abuse (90)
  - Joking about tasering (4)
  - Journalists tasered (1)
  - Karbon Arms Inc. (10)
  - Killed-by-cop provocation (3)
  - Lack of transparency (78)
  - Land occupation (“squatters”) (2)
  - Language misunderstanding (2)
  - Laughter (4)
  - Lawsuits against correctional authorities (6)
  - Lawsuits against municipalities (110)
  - Lawsuits against TASER Inc. (45)
  - Lazy cop syndrome (18)
  - Legislation (59)
  - Liability lawsuits (66)
  - Life-cycle 5 years (4)
  - Ligue des droits et libertes (Quebec) (4)
  - Ligue des Noirs du Québec (7)
  - Long Range Acoustic Device (LRAD) (3)
  - Low-cost housing (2)
  - LSD (4)
  - Manic depression (5)
  - Marijuana (10)
  - Marijuana – cause of death (5)
  - Medecine (38)
  - Media jokes about tasers (12)
  - Medical advice to people tasered (1)
  - Medical expenses post-tasering (4)
  - Medical tests following taser use (9)
  - Mental disability (25)
  - Mental Health Foundation (New Zealand) (2)
  - Metal Storm (MAUL) (Australia) (2)
  - Methamphetamine (14)
  - Military training (7)
  - Military users (91)
  - Military-police link-up (23)
  - Misdemeanor – then tasered (1)
  - Mistaken identity (18)
  - Moratorium (37)
  - Multiple taser discharges (292)
  - Municipal hearings on tasers (16)
  - NAACP (USA) (8)
  - Nat Assoc of Medical Examiners (USA) (2)
  - Nat. Alliance on Mental Illness (USA) (4)
  - National Alliance on Mental Illness (USA) (1)
  - National Rifle Association (NRA: USA) (5)
  - National Sheriffs Assoc (USA) (1)
  - New adoption (80)
  - New products on trial (65)
  - New research into tasers (16)
  - No known cause of death (2)
  - Non-lethal arms (118)
  - Nude victimes (4)
  - Nudity (5)
  - Nudity at sports events (3)
  - Nursing home (1)
  - Obesity (5)
  - Occupy Wall Street (etc.) (12)
  - Official Inquiry into tasers (35)
  - Official report (33)
  - Ombudsman (7)
  - Opposition political party (12)
  - Organized crime (5)
  - Pain (78)
  - Paramilitary use (11)
  - Park Police (USA) (2)
  - Parkinson’s disease (1)
  - Parliamentary security (1)
  - PCP (4)
  - Pension fund (2)
  - Pepper gun instead of taser (3)
  - Pepper Spray deaths (2)
  - Pet dog tasered (2)
  - Pet-owner tasered (1)
  - Petition against tasers (8)
  - Petition for tasers (1)
  - Petrol-sniffing (2)
  - Phobia about safety (2)
  - Physical disability (3)
  - Physically handicapped (3)
  - Pilots (6)
  - Pneumonia (1)
  - Police – Information about excited delirium (15)
  - Police accountability (308)
  - Police Action Centre (PAC-UK) (2)
  - Police Action Centre (UK) (1)
  - Police agencies (USA) (1)
  - Police apologize for tasering (11)
  - Police as taser salesmen (11)
  - Police attitudes to tasers (366)
  - Police beliefs about tasers (120)
  - Police college training (2)
  - Police communications skills (15)
  - Police complaints commissions (21)
  - Police criticize tasers (20)
  - Police culture (202)
  - Police demanding more tasers (22)
  - Police deny taser use (3)
  - Police differential use (4)
  - Police Executive Research Forum (PERF: USA) (3)
  - Police exonerated (65)
  - police failing course (1)
  - Police generation gap (2)
  - Police hesitation to use taser (8)
  - Police indicted (55)
  - Police injuries after taser adoption (7)
  - Police insensitivity (22)
  - Police Investigating police (17)
  - Police less access to tasers (2)
  - Police misreporting (63)
  - Police mistaking gun for taser (4)
  - Police not following guidelines (9)
  - Police not obeying limitations (36)
  - Police officer tasered (1)
  - Police perjury (22)
  - Police punished for taser abuse (18)
  - Police refused access to tasers (40)
  - Police required to carry tasers (3)
  - Police sensitivity to psychiatric problems (41)
  - Police tasering colleague (4)
  - Police testimony at trials (3)
  - Police threaten to electrocute (10)
  - Police turn off video cameras (2)
  - Police under stress (15)
  - Police unions (68)
  - Police using TASER Inc. statistics (7)
  - Police using taser off-duty (2)
  - Police view on tasers (20)
  - Police with TASER cameras (6)
  - Police/Community relations (19)
  - Political convention (1)
  - Positional Asphyxia (2)
  - Post-traumatic stress disorder (1)
  - Prison (89)
  - Prison guards refused tasers (2)
  - Prisons – Guards demand tasers (3)
  - Privacy and body-worn cameras (1)
  - Privacy problems (1)
  - Private security services (4)
  - Pro-Tect Systems (UK) (13)
  - Project Stealth (1)
  - Protecting diplomats (2)
  - Protecting politicians (2)
  - Protest over taser death (5)
  - Protest over taser use (5)
  - Protesters (78)
  - Psychiatric population (309)
  - Psychological effects (7)
  - Public access to taser use (7)
  - Public Meeting on tasers (11)
  - Public opinion poll (10)
  - Qualified immunity (1)
  - Racism (62)
  - RCMP Public Complaints Commission (Canada) (1)
  - Reduction in taser use (13)
  - Religious extremists (1)
  - Religious minorities (2)
  - Replacing X26 with X2 (16)
  - Research methodology (27)
  - Research: RESTRAINT project (Canada) (1)
  - Rethink Mental Illness (UK) (2)
  - Riot control (12)
  - Rise – award (TASER-PoliceOne) (4)
  - Robberies (23)
  - Robots for tasers (3)
  - Royal family (6)
  - Run-over by police (1)
  - Running amok (1)
  - Sanctions against police (6)
  - Schizophrenia (27)
  - Schools (36)
  - Sedatives (1)
  - Serious culture reference (1)
  - Settlement by city (5)
  - Settlements for abuse (97)
  - Severe injury (19)
  - Sex offender (1)
  - Sexism (6)
  - Sexual abuse (6)
  - Shop-lifting (3)
  - Shot then tasered (6)
  - Sickle-cell disease (1)
  - Slander lawsuits (SLAPP) (7)
  - SMP technologies (Taser-France) (4)
  - SMU-100 laser weapon (1)
  - Smuggling (3)
  - Social networking (2)
  - Soft intervention techniques (8)
  - Solitary confinement (3)
  - Southern Christian Leadership Conference (1)
  - Special Investigations Unit (SIU, Ontario) (8)
  - Special needs (no details) (1)
  - Spitting at police (3)
  - Split-second decision-making (4)
  - Sports events (9)
  - Squatters (1)
  - Statistics on tasers (302)
  - Steroids (2)
  - Streaking (1)
  - Striking workers (3)
  - Stroke victim (3)
  - Stun shield (1)
  - Suffocation (1)
  - Suicide prevention (75)
  - Survey on tasers (1)
  - Tactical Safety Responses Ltd (UK) (1)
  - Tagging (8)
  - Taser abuse (up to 2011) (375)
  - Taser after eviction (2)
  - Taser as a humanitarian tool (6)
  - Taser as deterrent (1)
  - TASER as sole-supplier (3)
  - TASER buyback (1)
  - TASER Cam (22)
  - TASER cartridge sales (8)
  - Taser causes confused response (5)
  - Taser causes riot (1)
  - Taser causing back injury (2)
  - Taser causing brain damage (2)
  - Taser causing coma (9)
  - Taser causing eye injury (11)
  - Taser causing miscarriage (1)
  - Taser causing suicide (2)
  - Taser causing violent response (7)
  - Taser competitors (4)
  - TASER consultants (9)
  - TASER Cordless (4)
  - TASER cost per unit (22)
  - Taser creep (93)
  - Taser demonstration mode (39)
  - Taser demonstration mode (7)
  - Taser download data (14)
  - Taser dysfunctioning (19)
  - Taser enforcing morality (1)
  - TASER export regulations (4)
  - TASER Family Protection System (3)
  - Taser gamechanger (1)
  - TASER global sales (23)
  - TASER Grenade Launcher (3)
  - TASER Head-held camera (6)
  - Taser imports to USA (1)
  - TASER Inc. & medical examiners (2)
  - TASER Inc. & the S.E.C. (USA) (7)
  - TASER Inc. (India) (2)
  - TASER Inc. aggressive defense (51)
  - TASER Inc. answering criticism (29)
  - TASER Inc. board-members (6)
  - TASER Inc. chest advisory (36)
  - TASER Inc. corporate-funded research (37)
  - TASER Inc. disclaimer/covenant (9)
  - TASER Inc. disinformation (40)
  - TASER Inc. distributors (7)
  - TASER Inc. employee harrassment (1)
  - TASER Inc. explains itself (15)
  - TASER Inc. failure to warn of danger (8)
  - TASER Inc. founding myths (4)
  - TASER Inc. French distributor (SMP) (29)
  - TASER Inc. funding politicians (3)
  - TASER Inc. funds police foundations (5)
  - TASER Inc. in-house history (10)
  - TASER Inc. liability lawsuits (22)
  - TASER Inc. lobbyists (3)
  - TASER Inc. military sales-order (5)
  - TASER Inc. monopoly supplier (24)
  - TASER Inc. out-of-court settlement (41)
  - TASER Inc. personality cult (2)
  - TASER Inc. press releases (67)
  - TASER Inc. prosecutes journalists (1)
  - TASER Inc. public relations (37)
  - TASER Inc. settlements (13)
  - TASER Inc. speaks out (64)
  - TASER Inc. statistics on overseas sales (17)
  - TASER Inc. uses social media (5)
  - TASER Inc. warranty on products (6)
  - TASER Inc.’s political connections (4)
  - Taser inciting violence (2)
  - Taser inconvenient (1)
  - Taser increased access (44)
  - Taser ineffective (26)
  - TASER Information summits (2)
  - Taser inherently dangerous (8)
  - Taser instructor’s course (10)
  - TASER International EUROPE S.E (1)
  - Taser Lawyers as experts (2)
  - Taser lost by police (2)
  - TASER manufacturing (8)
  - TASER manufacturing partner (4)
  - Taser medical emergency (10)
  - Taser new purchases (17)
  - TASER overseas sales (74)
  - TASER Parental Control (3)
  - Taser patent (4)
  - Taser penetrating brain (1)
  - Taser perceived as toy (18)
  - Taser protecting victims (3)
  - Taser protecting women from rape (3)
  - Taser retrofitting (1)
  - Taser rollout (99)
  - Taser sales methods (41)
  - TASER sales to general public (45)
  - Taser saving lives (TASER Inc. claims) (47)
  - TASER Shield (1)
  - TASER Shockwave (4)
  - TASER StrikeLight (1)
  - Taser stun mode (4)
  - TASER technology summit (2)
  - Taser training (173)
  - Taser training vs. CIT (7)
  - Taser trial (try-out) (66)
  - Taser trivialization (14)
  - Taser use against journalists (3)
  - Taser use down (7)
  - Taser use on hunger striker (2)
  - Taser use potentially appropriate (3)
  - Taser use regulations (2)
  - Taser use up (20)
  - TASER Wildlife (5)
  - Taser withdrawn following death (8)
  - TASER X12 (15)
  - TASER X2 (25)
  - TASER X26 (1)
  - TASER X26P (3)
  - TASER X3 (11)
  - TASER XREP (extended range) (38)
  - Tasercam video evidence (8)
  - Tasered from moving vehicle (1)
  - Tasered then shot (14)
  - Tasered while handcuffed (11)
  - Tasered-then-died (2012-04 +) (197)
  - Tasergate (Albuquerque) (1)
  - Tasers differential use (7)
  - Tasers to combat drug abuse (1)
  - TASR – Insider trading (8)
  - TASR – Share prices (51)
  - TASR shares and foreign sales (12)
  - Teenagers targeted (82)
  - Tender for stun-guns (4)
  - Tent city (1)
  - Terrorism (25)
  - Testing & reliability (71)
  - Testosterone (1)
  - Threats to use taser (20)
  - Threshold for using taser (1)
  - Torture (74)
  - Torture weapon (taser) (34)
  - Toy gun mistaken for taser (1)
  - Trade unions (1)
  - trademark infringement lawsuit (2)
  - Traffic stop (22)
  - Transit workers (3)
  - Trident 23 (1)
  - UN Committee against torture (CAT) (24)
  - UN Human Rights Committee (2)
  - UN Peace-keeping mission (5)
  - Uniform taser training (1)
  - United Nations (general) (15)
  - University of Miami Brain Bank (12)
  - University security services (13)
  - University students (15)
  - US Export license approvals (2)
  - US Fourth amendment rights (3)
  - US Justice Department (5)
  - US Military helping sales (6)
  - US Second amendment rights (2)
  - US Securities and Exchange Commission (2)
  - US Supreme Court (8)
  - Use in courtroom (1)
  - Use-of-force scale (42)
  - Victims speak out (26)
  - Videos (82)
  - Vievu body-held cameras (2)
  - Vigil (1)
  - Volunteer laughing (4)
  - Volunteer lawsuits (12)
  - Volunteer police death (1)
  - Volunteer police for charity (3)
  - Volunteer police for tasering (59)
  - Volunteer police injured (18)
  - Volunteer police refuse tasering (5)
  - Volunteers (TASER Inc.) (3)
  - Water dangers (2)
  - Weapon of choice (40)
  - Weapon of last resort (8)
  - Whistle-blower (2)
  - Witness tasered (1)
  - Women’s self-protection (1)
  - Workmen’s compensation (2)
  - Youths using tasers (5)

Archive for the 'Alberta Serious Incident Response Team (ASIRT)' Category

CANADA – Edmonton, Alberta: ASIRT confirms Taser used on man, 39, during arrest, (2013-10-28)

Posted on October 28 2013 by admin

[[SUMMARY / COMMENTS: The Alberta Serious Incident Response Team that an unnamed man in serious condition in hospital had been tasered, following a fight between a man and a woman on October 24th. His age is 39. No further information is being released (such as whether he was tasered 3 times, as a witness has […]

CANADA – Edmonton Police not responsible for death of Tasered man with ‘super-human’ strength [Jeff Oatway in 2012] (2013-09-05)

Posted on September 5 2013 by admin

[[SUMMARY / COMMENTS : The Alberta Serious Incident Response Team (ASIRT) has concluded that Edmonton police are not responsible for the in-custody death of a 34-yr-old Jeff Oatway who was Tasered on April 11, 2012. He was clearly out-of-control (read: psychiatric distress) and the taser “had no effect and he continued to struggle” (?). While […]